AP Biology · Unit 6 lecture · Part 8 of 11 · 7 min

6.6 Gene expression and cell specializationSame genes, different cells

Mrs. Otero
Here's one of the deepest ideas in biology. A neuron and a muscle cell in your body carry exactly the same DNA. So why does one fire signals and the other contract? It's not which genes they have. It's which genes they use.

In eukaryotes, RNA polymerase can't start transcription by itself. Proteins called transcription factors must first bind to the promoter and help RNA polymerase attach. Other transcription factors bind to enhancers, regulatory sequences that can sit far upstream or downstream of the gene, even thousands of bases away. The DNA bends or loops so that an activator on an enhancer can reach the promoter and boost transcription. Negative regulators (repressors) can bind regulatory sequences too and block transcription.

enhanceractpromotergenepolactivator + transcriptionfactors recruit RNA polmore transcriptionDNA loops
An activator bound to a distant enhancer. The DNA loops so the activator and other transcription factors can help RNA polymerase start at the promoter.
?Wait, how does a signal from outside reach the DNA?
In cell signaling (Unit 4), a signal binds a receptor and a signal transduction pathway carries the message inside. Many pathways end by activating a transcription factor, which changes the expression of specific genes. That's how a hormone can change what a cell makes.

Each gene's regulatory sequences work like a lock that needs a particular set of keys. A gene is transcribed only in cells that contain the right combination of transcription factors. Different cell types make different combinations of transcription factors, so they express different sets of genes. The result is differential gene expression: cells with the same genome specialize into liver, muscle or nerve cells by making tissue-specific proteins.

Gene forLiver cellMuscle cellNerve cell
A glycolysis enzymeononon
Albumin (blood protein)onoffoff
Myosin (muscle motor)offonoff
A neurotransmitter receptoroffoffon
DNA present?all genesall genesall genes
Every cell has every gene. Housekeeping genes, like those for glycolysis, are on everywhere; tissue-specific genes are on only in some cells.

During development, transcription factors switch on in a sequence: early transcription factors turn on genes for later ones, which turn on the next set, and so on. That cascade is how a single fertilized egg becomes an organism with hundreds of cell types. And one transcription factor can control many genes at once if they all share the same regulatory sequence, which lets a cell switch on a whole program, like the response to a hormone, together.

?Wait, what's the difference between a gene and an allele here?
A gene is the stretch of DNA for one product. Every cell in your body has the same genes, with the same alleles you inherited. Specialization changes which genes are expressed, not which genes or alleles a cell has.
Pause and think
A skin cell and a liver cell from the same person are compared. Which will be the same: their DNA, their mRNA, or their proteins?
I thought about it. Show me
Their DNA (apart from rare mutations). Their mRNAs and proteins differ, because each cell type expresses a different set of genes. That difference in expression is what makes them different cell types.
Combinatorial control
Gene X is transcribed only when activators A and B are both bound to its enhancer. Gene Y needs activator A, and is blocked whenever repressor R is present. Liver cells contain A and B. Muscle cells contain A and C. Nerve cells contain B and R. Predict whether X and Y are expressed in each cell type.
  1. Liver (A, B): X has both A and B, so on. Y has A and no R, so on.
  2. Muscle (A, C): X lacks B, so off. Y has A and no R, so on.
  3. Nerve (B, R): X lacks A, so off. Y lacks A and has R, so off.
    Why?
    Either missing A or the presence of R would be enough to keep Y off.
  4. Conclusion: the same two genes, present in every cell, give three different patterns of expression because each cell type has a different combination of transcription factors.

Answer: Liver: X on, Y on. Muscle: X off, Y on. Nerve: X off, Y off.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Make a small table: cell types across, genes down.
  2. For X, check for both A and B.
  3. For Y, check for A, then check that R is absent.
Check yourself
Liver cells make albumin, but skin cells from the same person do not. Which explanation is best supported?
  1. ASkin cells have lost the albumin gene during development.
  2. BLiver cells contain transcription factors that activate the albumin gene, and skin cells lack them.
  3. CThe albumin gene has a different DNA sequence in skin cells.
  4. DSkin cells translate albumin mRNA, but the protein is destroyed at once.
Show the answer

B. Both cells have the albumin gene. Liver cells express it because they have the right transcription factors to switch it on: differential gene expression. Losing or changing the gene is the trap; specialization changes expression, not the DNA.

  • Eukaryotic transcription needs transcription factors at the promoter; activators at enhancers (near or far) increase it; repressors decrease it.
  • Each cell type has its own combination of transcription factors, so it expresses its own set of genes: differential gene expression.
  • Same genome, different cells. Specialization comes from tissue-specific proteins.
  • In development, transcription factors switch on in sequence.