6.2 Replication: the modelCopying DNA: half old, half new

Watson and Crick noticed that if the two strands separate, each one carries everything needed to rebuild the other: wherever there's an A, the new strand gets a T, and so on. That suggests semiconservative replication: each new double helix keeps one old (parental) strand and gets one newly built strand. But two other models were possible too.
?Wait, what's an isotope again?
In 1958, Matthew Meselson and Franklin Stahl tested the models. They grew bacteria for many generations on heavy nitrogen (15N), so all of their DNA was heavy. Then they moved the bacteria to ordinary nitrogen (14N), let them divide, and spun samples of DNA in a centrifuge tube where molecules settle at a height that matches their density: heavy DNA lower, light DNA higher.
After one round of replication, all the DNA formed a single band halfway between heavy and light. That ruled out the conservative model, which predicts one heavy band and one light band. After a second round, there were two bands, hybrid and light, in equal amounts. That ruled out the dispersive model, which predicts a single band that drifts gradually toward light. Only semiconservative replication fits both results.
| Generation in 14N | Heavy (15N/15N) | Hybrid (15N/14N) | Light (14N/14N) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 100% | 0% | 0% |
| 1 | 0% | 100% | 0% |
| 2 | 0% | 50% | 50% |
| 3 | 0% | 25% | 75% |
I thought about it. Show me
- (a) One round. Conservative: one heavy band and one light band. Semiconservative: one hybrid band. Dispersive: one hybrid band.
Why?
Semiconservative and dispersive both put half old, half new material in every molecule after one round. - (b) Two rounds. Conservative: heavy and light bands (1 heavy : 3 light). Semiconservative: hybrid and light bands, 1 : 1. Dispersive: a single band between hybrid and light.
Why?
Dispersive molecules all have the same mix of old and new pieces, so they form one band. - (c) The single hybrid band after one round rules out conservative replication. The two separate bands (hybrid and light) after two rounds rule out dispersive replication.
Answer: (a) Conservative: heavy + light; semiconservative and dispersive: one hybrid band. (b) Conservative: heavy + light; semiconservative: hybrid + light; dispersive: one in-between band. (c) Round 1 rules out conservative; round 2 rules out dispersive.
Stuck? Get a hint
- Draw two strands per molecule, colored old or new.
- Ask whether any molecule is made only of old strands.
- Dispersive gives every molecule the same mix, so only one band.
- A1/2
- B1/4
- C1/8
- D0
Show the answer
B. Three rounds turn 1 molecule into 8. Only the 2 original heavy strands remain, each in its own hybrid molecule: 2/8 = 1/4. The other 6 are all light. 1/8 counts only one of the two old strands.
- Replication is semiconservative: each new helix has one parental strand and one new strand.
- Meselson and Stahl: one hybrid band after one round (rules out conservative), hybrid plus light after two (rules out dispersive).
- Each strand serves as a template for a complementary new strand.