AP Biology · Unit 5 lecture · Part 11 of 12 · 6 min

5.5 Environmental effects on phenotypeSame genes, different outcomes

Mrs. Otero
Here's a question students rarely ask: if two organisms have exactly the same genes, will they look the same? Not necessarily. Genes set the possibilities, and the environment helps decide which possibilities come true.

Genes are not always on or off. Their expression, how much RNA and protein they make, can respond to the environment: temperature, light, nutrients, pH, the presence of predators. When one genotype produces different phenotypes in different environments, that's called phenotypic plasticity. The DNA sequence doesn't change. Gene expression does.

?Wait, what's gene expression?
Gene expression is a gene being used: transcribed into RNA and, for most genes, translated into protein. A cell can turn genes up, down, on or off. You'll study exactly how in Unit 6.
OrganismEnvironmental factorPhenotype that changes
HydrangeaSoil pHFlowers blue in acidic soil, pink in basic soil
Some turtles and alligatorsEgg incubation temperatureSex of the hatchling
Arctic fox, snowshoe hareSeason (day length, temperature)White coat in winter, brown in summer
HumansNutrition and healthHeight and weight
Some plantsDamage from herbivoresMore hairs or spines on new leaves
Examples of phenotypic plasticity.

Some examples are dramatic. In many turtles, the temperature of the nest decides whether an egg hatches as a male or a female. Arctic foxes grow white fur in winter and brown fur in summer, with the same genes all year. Hydrangeas bloom blue in acidic soil and pink in basic soil. And human height depends on many genes plus nutrition and health during childhood, which is one reason average heights have changed over generations.

To see plasticity in an experiment, biologists hold the genotype constant and change the environment. Plants are perfect for this, because cuttings from one plant are clones with identical DNA. A graph of phenotype across environments for each genotype is called a reaction norm.

10152025300102030405060growing temperature (°C)plant height (cm)clone 1clone 2clone 3
Model data: cuttings from three plants (clones) grown at three temperatures. Each line is one genotype. The lines have different slopes, so genotype and environment interact.
?Wait, what's a controlled variable?
A controlled variable is something kept the same in every group of an experiment, so it can't explain the results. Here, using clones holds the genotype constant, so any difference in height between temperatures must come from the environment.
Pause and think
In the graph, which clone is tallest at 10 °C, and which is tallest at 30 °C? What does that tell you about the idea of a single "best" genotype?
I thought about it. Show me
Clone 3 is tallest at 10 °C (45 cm), but clone 1 is tallest at 30 °C (50 cm). Which genotype does best depends on the environment, so there is no single best genotype. That matters for natural selection in Unit 7.
Design and interpret
A student plants cuttings of one hydrangea in pots of soil at pH 5.0, 6.0 and 7.5 and records flower color. (a) Identify the independent variable, the dependent variable and one controlled variable. (b) Why use cuttings from one plant? (c) Plants at pH 5.0 bloom blue and plants at pH 7.5 bloom pink. Did the soil change the plants' genes? Explain.
  1. (a) Independent variable: soil pH. Dependent variable: flower color. Controlled: genotype (all clones), plus pot size, water and light.
    Why?
    The independent variable is the one the experimenter changes on purpose.
  2. (b) Cuttings are genetically identical, so differences in color can't be due to different alleles. Genotype becomes a controlled variable.
  3. (c) No. The DNA sequence is the same in all the plants. The environment changed how the plants express their genes and build pigment, so the same genotype produced different phenotypes: phenotypic plasticity.
    Why?
    Avoid "the environment changed the genes". Say it changed gene expression.

Answer: (a) IV: soil pH; DV: flower color; controlled: genotype (clones), water, light. (b) Identical genotypes rule out genetic differences. (c) No: the environment changed gene expression, not the DNA, so this is phenotypic plasticity.

Stuck? Get a hint
  1. Which factor did the student set on purpose?
  2. What do all cuttings of one plant share?
  3. Plasticity changes expression, never the sequence.
Check yourself
Genetically identical water fleas grow tall protective head spines when raised with chemicals released by their predators, and no spines without them. This is best described as:
  1. Aa mutation caused by the predator chemicals
  2. Bphenotypic plasticity: the environment changes gene expression
  3. Cincomplete dominance of the spine allele
  4. Dnatural selection acting within one generation
Show the answer

B. Same genotype, different phenotype depending on the environment: phenotypic plasticity. The chemicals don't mutate the DNA; they change which genes are expressed. Natural selection acts on populations over generations, not within one individual.

  • Phenotypic plasticity: one genotype, different phenotypes in different environments.
  • The environment changes gene expression, not the DNA sequence.
  • Examples: soil pH and hydrangea color, temperature and turtle sex, season and fur color, nutrition and height.
  • Experiments hold genotype constant (clones) and vary the environment.